Between 1833 and 1901, the inhabitants of Vitoria experienced a violent climate of “fla-flu”, one of the most persistent conflicts in the history of Espirito Santo. Driven by the devotion of San Benedito, the inhabitants of the capital at that time split into two groups: the peroa, who met at Igreja do Rosario in the lower part of the capital; and their opponents, the Karamuru, who attended Mass at the San Francisco Convent in the Upper City.

The brawl, which was initially over a controversy over who would post the image of San Benedito, was taken seriously and influenced clothing, music, culture and even local politics. Members of the Conservative Party, which supported the empire and the slave system, sided with the Karamuru, who represented the wealthier classes in the city.

The Liberal Party, on the other hand, adhered to republican ideals and advocated the abolition of slavery, sided with the poorest inhabitants of Peroa, many of whom were still slaves. Despite this preliminary definition, there were some exceptions, both rich people from the Peroa and poorer people who stayed with the Karamuru.

The rivalry was such that on several occasions it actually came to a fight with physical aggression between the two groups. There are reports of simultaneous processions of two brotherhoods that met along the way and turned the religious district into a battlefield. In fact, the terms karamuru and feathera, fish of little commercial value at the time, were used by adversaries on either side as a way to provoke rivals.

Historian Fernando Aciame says that in the early years of the fight, when it was more intense, there was no one who remained neutral without choosing a side. Green flags were flown in the houses of the city of Karamuru, and the feathers adopted blue as the color of their brotherhood. Religious clothing also matched the colors of each group.

The Peroas, who took refuge in Igreja do Rosario, nicknamed their enemies caramurus because of the greenish color of the fish, which resembled an eel, and because this animal was considered aggressive fishermen who made up the majority of the free workers. in Vitória. during that period. Caramurus, on the other hand, used the term peroá derogatoryly to refer to their enemies, as it is a bluish fish and is often despised in fishing.

“The ancients said that the ladies of Peroa wore the blue robes of their party on holidays, but wore green shoes or slippers. When asked why they did this, they replied that they had stepped on their opponents. The opposite has been done to the women from the Karamuru faction – green dresses but blue shoes, ”says Achiame.

San Benedito, a Franciscan monk of black descent, canonized in Europe, had great devotion among the capixabs, especially among the African peoples who were enslaved. In a nineteenth-century shipwreck off the coast of the state, survivors who were rescued by clinging to the mast of the ship considered the saint’s protection a miracle in this episode. This is where the traditional binding of a mast in honor of a monk originated.

The San Benedito festivities, celebrated on December 26, were one of the main events in the capital, during which a procession was held to carry the saint from the San Francisco convent to the lower part of the city. The Brotherhood of San Benedito, made up of believers, organized the entire celebration.

However, in 1832, on the day of the festival, the city had a rainy climate, so the monk Manoel de Santa Ursula, who was then in charge of the monastery, did not allow the image of San Benedito to be taken to the procession. Some members, dissatisfied with the monk’s decision, tried to dissuade him, but to no avail.

A few days later, when he learned that the brotherhood was criticizing him, the monk ordered all the items of the group to be thrown out the window of the monastery and locked the image of St. Benedict in a cell. It was from there that some members began to gather in the church of Nossa Senhora do Rosario in the lower part of the city, where they founded a new brotherhood.

In 1833, when the monk Manoel de Santa Ursula left Espiritu Santo, the new monk took over the monastery and released the image of San Benedito, which was replaced on the altar. However, in September of that year, a new brotherhood formed in Igreja do Rosario kidnapped the saint so that he could remain in the lower part of the city.

As members of the old brotherhood, those who continued to attend Mass in the San Francisco convent, also declared this image, a feud began that lasted until 1901, when the Archdiocese of Vitoria, led by Dom Fernando Monteiro, brother of Geronimo Monteiro, determined the end of the procession of brotherhoods. …

During the entire period of their existence, when quarrels became more and more frequent, it was decided that for six months a year the image would remain in the monastery, the stronghold of the Karamurs, and the rest of the year in the church where the feathers met.

According to historian Fernando Aciame, there are records that the two fraternities entered into a truce and made peace on May 13, 1888, during celebrations dedicated to the abolition of slavery. While conservatives (predominantly among the Karamurs) and liberals (mainly among liberals) stood for the end of slavery.

“During the Empire, the Karamura were identified with the conservatives, and the feather with the liberals, but it must be borne in mind that at that time many people did not have access to the vote. In addition, the political system was very centralized. Achiame.

With the beginning of the republic, political divisions between the two groups began to fade. However, the religious dispute, although much less aggressive than during the imperial period, continued for several more years.

“After the proclamation of the republic, the differences have subsided somewhat. Compared to the current reality, it was like a family that supports the same football team, but its members can make their political choices in different ways, ”he compares.

In sport, fraternities also influenced the creation of two regatta clubs, as rowing was the most popular sports category at the time. Karamur boats were painted green, and feather boats were blue. During the debates, fans also painted themselves and raised flags.

More than a century after the end of the feud, the greatest legacy left from the controversy is the name given to the viaduct, built in 1927, which stands today in the upper part of Vitoria. The Karamuru Viaduct was named after the San Francisco Convent, the former seat of the brotherhood.

According to political scientist and historian João Gualberto Vasconcellos, the historical dispute between the peroás and the caramurus reflects the social inequality that characterized the city at a time when the majority of Vitoria’s inhabitants consisted of enslaved people, freedmen and their descendants.

“The dispute was a relic of a traditional society, which was organized mainly from religious myths. It is a dispute about the sacred, which determine the social order, on the one hand, those who have property during life, and on the other hand, the poorest. the fight escalated to the point that there was even an exchange of aggression. People left the house, ready to fight, “- emphasizes Vasconcellos.