Connect with us

Top News

Leftist Moral Superiority, Portuguese Exceptionalism, and Communist Denialism – Observer



Leftist Moral Superiority, Portuguese Exceptionalism, and Communist Denialism - Observer

You have free access to all Observer articles as a subscriber.

I regularly come across three phenomena that make political dialogue with our domestic left almost impossible: the first is a judgment of intention, when our actor assumes that anyone who is not “left” has perverse intentions and does not want the same. country and its fellow citizens. The second is what I call “Portuguese exclusivity,” a kind of doctrine based on the fact that our country is so exotic that it cannot be compared with anything else. Thus, this feature does not allow making any judgments based on what other countries could have done to solve the same problems that Portugal suffers from. The third phenomenon is that all communist and socialist regimes were not truly communist and socialist, and only someone especially malicious could claim such a hoax.

The process of intention consists in discrediting the person with whom they are at war, accusing his intentions of reprehensible, which cannot be proved and verified, leaves suspicion in the air that cannot be gotten rid of. In fact, this has the same effect on the dialogue as slow justice with the defendant: it destroys his reputation without bothering to prove something significant in a timely manner. In Portugal, this false argument has a rich history and has been consistently used by most of the most prominent leftists. Alvaro Cunjal published a small book in 1974 with the unambiguous title “Moral superiority of the communists“, Where it is stated that”[o comportamento moral da burguesia é] fierce individualism and selfishness, indifference to the fate of people, greed, venality, complete shamelessness, reduction of cultural and spiritual values ​​to simple goods“.

This Marxist leader then believes that all “bourgeois” are irrefutably corrupted and have the most terrible intentions. Boaventura Sousa Santos, another prominent thinker in the same political field, goes so far as to define what it means to be left and right as follows (“Portugal is a country more to the left or to the righta “, newspaper Público, 01.10.2015):

In a minimalist concept, the left is any political position that promotes all (or the vast majority) of the following goals: combating social inequality and discrimination through a virtuous articulation between the value of freedom and the value of equality in balance. between civil and political rights and social, economic and cultural rights; firm defense of pluralism in both the media and the economy, education and culture; democratization of the state through republican values, citizen participation and the independence of institutions, especially the judiciary; the struggle for memory and redress for those who have suffered (and are suffering) from violent forms of oppression; defending a strong concept of public opinion that balances diversity of opinion; protection of the national sovereignty and national sovereignty of other countries; peaceful resolution of internal and international conflicts. To be right is to be against all or the vast majority of these goals.


In short, being left is good, and being right is bad. For them and, unfortunately, for many of those who are under their influence, the concept of “left” has acquired a mystical, almost religious meaning. In recent months, I’ve been interested to hear many socialists advocate for this government budget (abolished by the PCP and BE) to be “left-most ever” in a wording that was actually synonymous with “best budget ever”. The hostages of this paradigm “left = good, right = bad” are not only the minds of communists and blockers, but also the majority of socialists, who, both in deed and in words, are more comfortable with the discourse of the radical left than with the centrism of much more successful workers and socialist parties in Europe.

The second characteristic I found was “Portuguese exclusivity.” Faced with the successes of the more liberal economies in Eastern Europe, they defend themselves by saying “we cannot compare the incomparable.” If we talk about the economic freedom of the Scandinavian social democracies, they reaffirm their conviction that we have nothing to do with them. And when we analyze the rapid growth of Ireland, Holland or Luxembourg, they reaffirm that Portugal is unique: either the size is different, or the religion is different, or the language is different, or the proximity to the centers of power is different, or the historical heritage is different.

The great interest of this kind of reasoning is that then you can offer any explanation for any problem, which, being impossible to prove counterfactual and without accepting any external comparisons, will allow you to safely, proudly and undeniably keep on top of your ignorance. … This is one of the most beautiful techniques of our media specialists. For example, they regularly use the euro as the root cause of our economic underdevelopment, ignoring the existence of so many other countries that have overtaken us using exactly the same currency. They respond to us with the excellent education of former communist countries, ignoring nearly half a century of democracy, which has given us more than enough time to deal with this and more. Almost our entire team was formed after the April revolution. Yes, comparisons are helpful. Especially to demonstrate what we need to change. We must always, regularly, carefully compare ourselves and draw conclusions in order to learn not only from our mistakes, but also from the successes and failures of others.

The third point that repeatedly appears in these discussions is communist denialism. When the communists and their later versions are confronted with the bottom line of the political systems they defend, they object by repeating that “this” is not true socialism / communism. That it was never implemented. In most cases, this resignation was always late and shameful, as we saw with the Chavez / Maduro duo, which caused great excitement until the hunger of the tortured Venezuelan people was no longer hidden. In a related and unfortunately forgotten demonstration, Free Party leader Rui Tavares accomplished the feat of never using the word “communist” in his article “In the careful death of genocide(Público, 09/07/2020) All about the genocide committed by the communist Pol Pot regime in Cambodia. As my communist friend would say much more openly when faced with Stalin’s crimes: this cannot be true, because a communist would never do that. Deep down, communist denialism turns out to be a less eloquent version of the moral superiority of the left. As so-called scientific ideologies, considered historically inevitable, they cannot afford to be wrong, which forces them to use methods of opacity and distortion of facts to defend the grand ultimate goal. Rather than distance themselves from these criminals, as the right does with Pinochet, Salazar, Mussolini or Hitler, they prefer to shy away, pretend, and hesitate.

There can be no presumption of moral superiority on either the left or the right. Aside from some of the more sinister characters, we all want the best for Portugal and for the Portuguese, disagreeing only on how best to get there. Comparison with other countries, especially those that bear some resemblance to ours, allows us to determine with great certainty what we must change in our institutions in order to achieve the same or better results. There is nothing inherently wrong with the Portuguese, as evidenced by their widespread success abroad. And it is time for politicians to take responsibility for the systems they defend, clearly separating themselves from genocidal and criminal policies, wherever and whenever they are carried out by people under their flags.

Of course, there are many serious people in all political fields, but we must stop silently accepting and violently condemning these more subtle political propaganda tricks. Political dialogue should take place through a sincere discussion of the validity and quality of each proposal, whether left or right, without judgment of intent, with serious comparative research, and with political and historical honesty.

I am not neutral on the political stage and do not demand neutrality from anyone, only loyalty and honesty in the political struggle. In my opinion, the experience of other countries clearly shows us the way forward. And this path is liberal. But I really appreciated the opportunity to discuss these proposals without taking into account the supposed moral superiority of the left, the ridiculous Portuguese exclusivity and depressing denial.I am a communist.

See also  Home of the Week: Easy life in Beverly Hills
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top News

Portuguese historical films will premiere on 29 December.



Portuguese historical films will premiere on 29 December.

Method Media Bermuda will present the documentary FABRIC: Portuguese History in Bermuda on Thursday, December 29 at the Underwater Research Institute of Bermuda.

A spokesperson said: “Method Media is proud to bring Bermuda Fabric: Portugal History to Bermuda for its 5th and 6th showing at the Bermuda Underwater Observatory. In November and December 2019, Cloth: A Portuguese Story in Bermuda had four sold-out screenings. Now that Bermuda has reopened after the pandemic, it’s time to bring the film back for at least two screenings.

“There are tickets For $ 20 – sessions at 15:30 and 18:00. Both screenings will be followed by a short Q&A session.

Director and producer Milton Raboso says, “FABRIC is a definitive account of the Portuguese community in Bermuda and its 151 years of history, but it also places Bermuda, Acors and Portugal in the world history and the events that have fueled those 151 years.

“It took more than 10 years to implement FABRIC. The film was supported by the Minister of Culture, the Government of the Azores and private donors.

Bermuda Media Method [MMB] Created in 2011 by producer Milton Raposo. MMB has created content for a wide range of clients: Bermuda’s new hospital renovation, reinsurance, travel campaigns, international sports and more. MMB pays special attention to artistic, cultural and historical content.

More about

#History of Bermuda #A photo #Portuguese

Model: Everybody, Entertainment, Movies/Movies, History, News

Continue Reading

Top News






This is a fact or event of journalistic interest. This may be new or recent information. This also applies to the novelty of an already known situation.


Mostly original text. Expresses the opinion of the author, but not necessarily the opinion of the newspaper. It can be written by journalists or specialists from different fields.


A report that contains unknown facts or episodes with a pronounced denunciatory content. This requires special methods and resources.

Content commerce

Editorial content that offers the reader conditions for making purchases.


This is the interpretation of the news, taking into account information that goes beyond the facts told. It uses data, brings events and scenario forecasts, as well as past contexts.


Analytical text translating the official position of the vehicle in relation to the facts covered.


This is an institutional article on a topic of interest to the company sponsoring the report.

fact checking

Content that confirms the accuracy and authenticity of the disclosed information or facts.


This is an article that brings subsidies, historical data and relevant information to help understand a fact or news.


An exciting report that details the various aspects and developments of this topic. It brings data, statistics, historical context, as well as stories of characters that are affected by or directly related to the topic in question.


A text with detailed analysis and opinions on products, services and works of art in a wide variety of fields such as literature, music, film and visual arts.

Continue Reading

Top News

Maestro de Braga is the first Portuguese in the National Symphony Orchestra of Cuba.



Maestro de Braga is the first Portuguese in the National Symphony Orchestra of Cuba.

Maestro Filipe Cunha, Artistic Director of the Philharmonic Orchestra of Braga, has been invited to conduct the Cuban National Symphony Orchestra, as announced today.

According to a statement sent by O MINHO, “he will be the first Portuguese conductor to conduct this orchestra in its entire history.”

In addition to this orchestra, the maestro will also work with the Lyceo Mozarteum de la Habana Symphony Orchestra.

The concerts will take place on 4 and 12 March 2023 at the National Theater of Cuba in Havana.

In the words of the maestro, quoted in the statement, “these will be very beautiful concerts with difficult but very complex pieces” and therefore he feels “very motivated”.

From the very beginning, Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 2 will be performed by an Italian pianist (Luigi Borzillo), whom the maestro wants to bring to Portugal later this year. In the same concert, Mendelshon’s First Symphony will be performed.

Then, at the second concert, in the company of the Mexican clarinetist Angel Zedillo, he will perform the Louis Sfora Concerto No. 2. In this concert, the maestro also conducts Tchaikovsky’s Fifth Symphony.

“This is an international recognition of my work. An invitation that I accept with humility and great responsibility. I was surprised to learn that I would be the first Portuguese member of the Cuban National Symphony Orchestra. This is a very great honor,” the maestro said in a statement.

“I take with me the name of the city of Braga and Portugal with all the responsibility that goes with it, and I hope to do a good job there, leaving a good image and putting on great concerts. These will be very special concerts because, in addition to performing pieces that I love, especially Rachmaninov and Tchaikovsky, I will be directing two wonderful soloists who are also my friends. It will be very beautiful,” concludes Filipe Cunha.

See also  Portuguese President calls early elections for January 30 - News

Continue Reading